Words of Gods

Comment on and discuss blog posts in here. One thread per post.
User avatar
Lilly Writer, Hanako Co-Writer, Producer
Posts: 1507
Joined: Mon Aug 20, 2007 3:10 am
Location: Australia

Re: Words of Gods

Post by Suriko » Tue Apr 12, 2011 6:37 am

ubergeneral wrote:first off katawa shoujo is special. Unlike other VNs each path has it's own writer. I can't think of any VNs that share this quality. However, in theory (this is coming from someone on the outside), each of the main girls is partially owned by their respective path writer. In other words, the person that should theoretically have the most say in what's cannon about their girl is the path writer. The result of this is each path has less overlap and can pretty much introduce any new character into it as the writer sees fit. I wouldn't be surprised if some of the characters that were in that CG do get smaller roles. Each path is going to need help having the story moved along, and while any of the main heroines could play that role many times those girls either don't know each other well or don't get along. For example I don't expect shizune to play a major role in Rin's path.
This is both true and untrue. The writers do have some ability to introduce new characters that are only, or primarily, used in their route (Akira is one example of this. She actually didn't appear in Act 1 at all until it was rewritten). That said, the writers definitely do not have free reign over their character's canon, nor can they introduce characters at will. The former is due to every character having to be a part of the overall cohesive narrative of KS - five writers getting to do their own thing would end up in a mess, so we all look over each other's work not only for continuity and general writing, but also for characterisation. As for the latter, adding characters, this is a huge decision that has generally meant (rightly) an uphill battle for the writer as they must justify their cool new character's reason for existence in the context of both the written narrative and also the required art assets.
ubergeneral wrote:As a reader and just by going off what I know about the game, i expect there to be more new characters to be added. And when they are the shimmie going to blow up and have artwork of them. In all honesty i think that yamaku is a interesting setting and I want the enviroment to be expanded more, characters that have started out as a backround have by fans been fleshed out and turned into interesting characters. If they only appeared in one CG it would be a waste.
There are new side characters yet to be introduced. The Shimmie has actually proved somewhat useful by throwing up such an insane amount of decoy targets that nobody seems too able to work out exactly which characters those are.
ubergeneral wrote:Or course the inverse of this is that too much of a good thing is really bad. Each path could potentially add a new character or flesh out part of yamaku, but there is a definite limit to what is good for the story and what detracts from the purpose and focus, which is always going to be the main girl and their relationship with Hisao.
This is true, and ties into my response to the first paragraph. I think every writer's wanted to add at least a couple of new characters that they really liked, but haven't been able to get them in, or have wanted to explore their existing side characters further, but haven't because it would detract from their heroine's story.
ubergeneral wrote:The bottom line is that the setting definitely needs to be expanded on to tell the story as well as just making it more intersting. But too much is a bad thing. I myself expect there to be more added and will welcome new characters and details. After all one of the best things about F/SN was that it was part of a bigger universe and it tied into that really well. It was one of the thing I liked more about it.
Again, yes and no. The game setting does expand beyond what is shown in Act 1, though as per the blog post, we didn't actively engage in making a world for multiple parts of a game franchise. That said, I would actually slightly disagree with Delta in that we are worldbuilders, simply by the fact that we are writing a fictional narrative. This, by virtue, means we created a unique world that is not identical to reality, whether we did it intentionally or unintentionally. I would argue the former for a few reasons, but with the caveat that we did not do so to the extent of Fate/Stay Night; we did not make the Katawa Shoujo world with the intention of using it any further than the Katawa Shoujo game itself, as Nasu very obviously did with F/SN.
ubergeneral wrote:Last is that if there are any "katawa shoujo gods" on this forum reading this post, please don't rain on my parade and tell me i'm wrong or that there won't be any more new characters, that would just be soul crushing.

User avatar
Posts: 1339
Joined: Sun May 03, 2009 11:36 pm

Re: Words of Gods

Post by Bara » Tue Apr 12, 2011 9:33 am

griffon8 wrote:
ubergeneral wrote:I really don't see a problem with expanding cannon.
I'm sorry, but you generally don't want your cannons expanding. Just the propellent that sends the shells at your target. :lol:
Ok, that got a snicker out of me this morning. :lol:

2xGPU clients (GTX 465/GTS 250); 2xCPU clients

<Aura> Our army of teenage girl artists couldn't draw penises without fits of giggling. Does that count?

User avatar
U.T. Raptor
Posts: 274
Joined: Thu May 07, 2009 12:50 am

Re: Words of Gods

Post by U.T. Raptor » Wed Apr 13, 2011 12:21 am

Suriko wrote: The Shimmie has actually proved somewhat useful by throwing up such an insane amount of decoy targets that nobody seems too able to work out exactly which characters those are.
...he says as if the devs weren't the only ones who can upload images to the thing :wink:

User avatar
Totz the Plaid
Posts: 156
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 1:39 am
Location: Eastpointe, Michigan, United States

Re: Words of Gods

Post by Totz the Plaid » Tue Apr 26, 2011 5:08 am

Mirage_GSM wrote:
delta wrote:For example, I have said before that Richter Bromont's depiction of the Yamaku principal as a Luchador wrestler is actually true. I know that there is nothing to contradict it in the game at this point (because he does not appear, and nor is mentioned in enough detail to make the call), so I'm not even outright lying. I just think it's funny, but does this make it "canon", an in-universe "truth"? I guess so, but I'm also aware that if we actually did decide to show him, he'd be something less... random. In fact, the principal did appear in an early draft, and in there she was a woman. Maybe THAT is more canonical than my offhand remark?
Well, it is only her voice but the principal does appear in Act 1, and at least in the German translation*, she will definitely be female - word of the great Suriko-sama 8)
So we already have a case of the words of two different gods creating conflicting pieces of canon-information.
Now, if you absolutely insist, we could change the principal's gender, but then you'd have to do another build and would probably rip our heads off...

*The german word for principal uses a different suffix for the male and the female version.**
**Increasing truthfulness of this post.
Conflicting information, you say? I beg to differ: http://luchawomen.blogspot.com/

Now, I prefer to believe that the head principal is a woman while it's the assistant principal that's a more stereotypically traditional male luchadore, at least until a Dev tells me otherwise as their word trumps fanon to me... but it's completely possible that Female!Principal and Luchadore!Principal are one in the same as Luchadora!Principal.
"There are worlds out there where the sky is burning, and the sea's asleep, and the rivers dream; people made of smoke and cities made of song. Somewhere there's danger, somewhere there's injustice, somewhere else the tea's getting cold. Come on, Ace. We've got work to do." - The Doctor, Doctor Who

Post Reply