Katawa Shoujo Forums

Smoku wrote:What if Rin suddenly grew her hair? Or Shizune?

How could Rin suddenly grow Shizune?

Smoku wrote:Wow, I mean... wow.

One of the girls let's her hair loose and soon a swarm of fans runs and drools towards her.

What if Rin suddenly grew her hair? Or Shizune?

I know I would be somewhat disappointed. My opinion remains: each of the girl's hair is perfect for them! I see no need to fix what isn't broken. Maybe we can let Emi loosen her hair a bit for one scene or something, but for me, those wacky pigtails are a part of Emi's character as much as her big, adorable eyes and her cute smile.

Smoku wrote:Or Shizune?

Funny, I prefer girls with longer hair, yet my favorite has the shortest hair of all the girls. Someone ought to draw Shizune with long hair, to explore this possibility.

G3n0c1de wrote:

Smoku wrote:Or Shizune?

Funny, I prefer girls with longer hair, yet my favorite has the shortest hair of all the girls. Someone ought to draw Shizune with long hair, to explore this possibility.

So, would a picture of Shizune with a beard down to her waist count as "long hair"?

Bara wrote:So, would a picture of Shizune with a beard down to her waist count as "long hair"?

And this is why we can't have nice things. Though if you jam Jigoro's head on Shizune's body...

Smoku wrote:Wow, I mean... wow.

One of the girls let's her hair loose and soon a swarm of fans runs and drools towards her.

You'd have to be a fairly boring person to not be curious how your favorite girls look with alternate hairstyles. A girl who occasionally sports a different hairstyle keeps herself interesting.

Smoku wrote:What if Rin suddenly grew her hair?

There's actually quite a few...
images of alternate RinHair...
on the shimmie.

[shimmie]398[/shimmie]
Also, popsicles.

^^^ Just look at her work on that popsicle.

From my perspective the original Emi sprite that was in the first version of Act one followed the design of the other chars, however the new version though seems to make it out of place in my opinion. I'm not an Emi fan, but I don't feel a symmetry in the sprite artwork that it originally had. That's just how it seems to me, but isn't going to stop me in anyway from playing the game when released since this is going to be a great game from what I can tell.

Hmmm... wrote:From my perspective the original Emi sprite that was in the first version of Act one followed the design of the other chars, however the new version though seems to make it out of place in my opinion.

You're entitled to your opinion, but I've got to disagree with you here. Old Emi's sprite didn't quite mesh with the other characters from a design standpoint - her uniform was a bit different, for example. The current rough sprites do stand out a bit because of the linework, but the design itself seems to work a bit better just as far as things like expressiveness and detailing go, and since the lines are getting cleaned up for the full release there should be no cause for alarm.

Whatever the case, I think it's safe to say that the devs won't let their several years' worth of work finally be released, only to risk having readers' immersion be compromised for an entire route by an out-of-place sprite set.

G3n0c1de wrote:Looks like Moekki also gave her a :3 face. Can't beat how Shizune's eyes change (>:3) when she does it, but I approve.

I hope there are more overexaggerated facial expressions in the game. Those are always the best.
http://img815.imageshack.us/img815/8946 ... dition.jpg Pic related.

Strong disagree.
Sprites like that or SD-sprites would simply kill the mood in KS.
That's not a comedy they're making here...
OK, it would kind of work with Kenji, but with no one else.

Mirage_GSM wrote:Strong disagree.
Sprites like that or SD-sprites would simply kill the mood in KS.
That's not a comedy they're making here...
OK, it would kind of work with Kenji, but with no one else.

There's always something to be said for well-timed comic relief, though. Stuff like Emi's o.o face or Shizune's >:3 seem to have turned out pretty adorable so far, but I agree that if it were taken to, say, Hidamari levels of chibiness, it might get a little silly. Either way, it probably just depends on the different artists' natural inclinations toward such things, although I don't foresee it happening too much anyway.

I'm not worried about it. So far the composition of the art has complemented the story being told without being any sort of distraction. Even when people commented they did not like the quality of a character in a drawing I can't remember anyone saying they thought the composition was off or it detracted from the story. The Dev's really have been able to maintain quite a good level of consistency across the board for the artwork. Considering the multitude of ways that things could have gone wrong with the art, it is mind boggling the way things have gone right! Really the only thing we obsessive fanboys have to nit-pick at is one set of sprites which the Dev's tell us are being brought to the same standards as the rest.

To me, it is amazing.