What you WOULD have wanted to happen in the story

[Smoku]

And yet there still is a large popularity for the Lilly dominatrix arrangement.

no wai.
I always viewed Lilly as the most tender princess-like refined and dignified character. Dominatrix fits Shizune way more.

...

But the Lilly figure in leather... does kinda spin my imagination.

[G3n0c1de]

I always viewed Lilly as the most tender princess-like refined and dignified character.

This is exactly why she fits this role. The irony of it all. Plus it's not that much of a stretch really, she could well have that hidden dark side. During the day she has to be prim, proper, and reserved. And at night she goes crazy with her gimp, Hanako. It's not like people would notice any new scars on her scarred side anyway. And should you choose Lilly, you can become her new gimp.

[Hanako in disguise]

And at night she goes crazy with her gimp, Hanako. It's not like people would notice any new scars on her scarred side anyway.

I... How... I don't even... WHY!?

But I agree that there is a lot of potential for interesting character exposition or developement in Lilly's case. She's just so painfully well-mannered and refined that you can't help but wonder what she hides behind that mask.

[Minister of Gloom]

And at night she goes crazy with her gimp, Hanako. It's not like people would notice any new scars on her scarred side anyway.

I... How... I don't even... WHY!?

But I agree that there is a lot of potential for interesting character exposition or developement in Lilly's case. She's just so painfully well-mannered and refined that you can't help but wonder what she hides behind that mask.

Lilly killed Hanako's parents.
It was her plan all along.

[Csihar]

Before this thread gets too derailed, might I point your pro-naughty-Lilly predilections in the general direction of Madame Lillian's Specialty Service?

I-It's not like I'm trying hard not to white knight or anything...

[neumanproductions]

Before this thread gets too derailed, might I point your pro-naughty-Lilly predilections in the general direction of Madame Lillian's Specialty Service?
I-It's not like I'm trying hard not to white knight or anything...

Where else do you think I get all these crazy ideas. They either come from me or my good pal Mr. Kosher. (I think that is one of the most referenced fics on the forums by now)
But please, its not like you can't hear Lilly saying, "I love hearing your screams of pleasure."
For Shizune I would see a masochist. That is MM! speaking out right now.

[Shintai]

Every time I try to imagine Lily in leather I just see her in a black lingerie.....

ANYWAYS, the reason I don't think Lily could fit the Yandere motif is just the simple fact that its hard to go nuts on people when you're blind unless you're Blind Samurai Zatoichi..... which I sincerely doubt Lily is capable of doing! (although it would be really cool if here little prod had a hidden blade or something)

[Burial_By_Fire]

LOL

Lilly owns leather.

What I want to see in the plot was inspired by the blackjack 4com in the shimmie. I want to have a scene where Rin wants to body paint Hanako's scars to make them colorful and do a nude photo shoot with her. Both the girls agree that Hisao should be the photographer.

[Smoku]

I LIKE the body paint thing!

[Linch]

I LIKE the body pain thing!

Masochist much.

[Smoku]

I LIKE the body painT thing!

Masochist much.

Fixed, oh Lord.

[EDiot]

I LIKE the body T-Pain thing!

Fix'd once more.

[Scarlet Fox]

Here to save the day and bring the thread back on topic.

I'd like to see another side to Rin. Maybe she's acting that way to cover up some sort of depression (sounds fairly reasonable, it's not uncommon for artists to feel that way).

Also I'd like to see some traumatic pasts -- well, maybe not, since Hanako has one. But I kind of want a traumatic past where some person does something bad to the character purposefully. Like a crazed man with a knife or a rapist or something. I want a character that there's something so bad about them/has happened to them you're kinda iffy about pursuing their path. But their disabilities kind of already make them more 'iffy' (even though no one here, including me, cares about it) than normal characters in VNs.

And I really want to see Emi using her legs as weapons (either she kicks someone or swings the detached leg and throws it or whacks someone over the head with it). Just as a comical scene, of course.

[Devon]

I want bad ends for every one of the girls if you try to play it out with two of them. Y'know, yandere-type stuff, like in School Days.

[AapoAlas]

Although I did enjoy School Days (the anime, though) I must say it did a horrible thing to the whole VN and anime / otaku scene. Suddenly horrible yandere-guro-endings are pop.