Katawa Shoujo Forums

What connection would writing a fanfic have with basic ability to analyze a story? :? A fanfic? Not a whole lot, necessarily. The widely-acknowledged preeminent fanfic of a whole fandom? Probably some correspondence between the ability to pick important things out of a story and to put important th...

Guest Poster wrote:So the 3 choices don't determine Lilly's growth, but rather Hisao's.

You're really good at this, y'know? It's almost like you wrote everyone's favorite fanfic or something…

Actually, Lilly's presence in the hospital in the second-to-last scene might have been a result of her temporary suspending her trip due to wanting to be with Hisao while he was recuperating. Personally, I think the event that REALLY caused Lilly to stay in Japan was Hisao essentially repeating the...

emmjay wrote:My vote for the saddest good end would be Lilly's.

Holy shit. The one answer I did not expect anyone to defend, boom, right off the bat. I thought Lilly's good end was supposed to be the ultimate feelgood fairy-tale fantasy of lollipops and rainbows? (Not my accusation, but a common one)

I think a guy named Fluff&Crunch wrote something like that some time ago. (if the threeway you have in mind is Hisao/Lilly/Hanako) Some people started posting M.Bison clips. Others shouted Bullshit. Mileage varied...a lot. Yeah, I saw that a few months into my work and got really scared. Luckil...

I just think it's hard to do well and convincingly while keeping the two in-character. Yuri-stories between Lilly and Hanako are a dime a dozen, but convincing ones...can't think of a single one. Ah, I see. Yeah, it's been tough in that regard. And the fact that there have been no fully serious att...

but reminded me of the original stories that you cannot," [this part escapes me slightly] " and we started thinking about writing "but it reminded me of one of the original stories we came up with when we started thinking about writing" something that actually made people cry.&q...

Guest Poster wrote:Trust me, I have no desire to stick my hand into that particular beehive.

Are you saying I'm going to get hate for it?

Still, if someone were to write a Hanako-Lilly pseudo-route based on Lilly's route with Hanako-route anxieties mixed in, I MIGHT just be able to stretch my suspension of disbelief enough not to immediately laugh it off, but it'd have to be written VERY well. Dammit to hell, I wish you guys would st...

Still, if someone were to write a Hanako-Lilly pseudo-route based on Lilly's route with Hanako-route anxieties mixed in, I MIGHT just be able to stretch my suspension of disbelief enough not to immediately laugh it off, but it'd have to be written VERY well. Dammit to hell, I wish you guys would st...

friedjellybeans wrote:I'm pretty sure the teacher was a devil-worshiper or something.

Was the teacher constantly telling everyone "I love you"?

Xanatos wrote:the most realistic of the lot.

If I wanted reality, I'd go back to my own crappy love life…

I have noticed that in this thread and others that people seem to take my less serious sentences (even humorous ones) as my objective opinion on the matter. For example the whole thing about Hanako not being a virgin and the lack of blood and a few other things. I was merely jesting hence the "...

I think nearly everyone is mad at Hisao at first just becasue we love Hanako too, and can't stand seeing her hurt. See, that's why I'm in such a minority on this. I wasn't mad at Hisao, even the first time through the scene. And I didn't even really see it as hurting her. Awkward, yes; uncomfortabl...

I can't tell you how much it gratifies me to see people coming to the same super-unpopular conclusions I did. Hanako did some wrong, Hisao did some wrong. A far cry from the annoying, simpleminded "it was rape" meme, to be sure, which to me is about a hundred times as white-knight-ey as an...